Natural rough diamond crystal showing characteristic octahedral form and triangular growth marks before cutting, on white background

Diamond Buying Guide: The 4Cs, Lab-Grown vs Natural, and What to Choose

A diamond's look comes down to the 4Cs: cut, color, clarity and carat weight, and cut matters most for how bright it looks. Lab-grown and natural diamonds are both diamond; the difference is origin and price. Here is how to read the 4Cs, how to choose between the two, and our gemologist's picks from $430.

Quick facts

The 4Cs Cut (how well it returns light), color (D is colorless, toward Z is warmer), clarity (inclusions) and carat (weight)
What matters most Cut. A well-cut smaller stone looks brighter than a poorly cut larger one
Durability 10 on the Mohs scale, the hardest gem. A hard knock on an edge can still chip it
Lab-grown vs natural The same carbon crystal. Natural formed deep in the Earth over billions of years; lab-grown is grown in weeks
Labeling Lab-grown must be described as lab-grown, laboratory-created or similar, right before the word diamond
Care Warm water, mild soap and a soft brush. Diamonds pick up skin oil, so a quick wash brings back the brightness

Choose a diamond by how you will wear it

Studs and huggies: lab-grown diamonds

Earrings are where most people start, and lab-grown diamonds make a bigger look affordable.

Lab-Grown Diamond Stud Earrings in Solid 14K Gold

Lab-Grown Diamond Stud Earrings in Solid 14K Gold

Made in the USA

From $430

Our gemologist: Lab-grown diamonds in four-prong 14K settings, VS clarity and F or better color, from 1/2 to 3 carats total. The same grade at every size, so you choose only the look.

Lab-Grown Diamond Huggie Hoop Earrings in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Lab-Grown Diamond Huggie Hoop Earrings in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Made in the USA

$480

Our gemologist: An 8mm hinged hoop with small lab-grown diamonds across the front. No separate back to lose, so it suits daily wear.

One diamond at the neck

A single round diamond is the classic first diamond necklace. Here the setting is the main choice.

1/2 Carat Lab-Grown Diamond Bezel Pendant in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

1/2 Carat Lab-Grown Diamond Bezel Pendant in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Made in the USA

$570

Our gemologist: A 1/2 carat lab-grown diamond in a smooth gold rim. The bezel guards the edge of the stone. The chain is sold separately.

1/2 Carat Lab-Grown Diamond Solitaire Necklace in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

1/2 Carat Lab-Grown Diamond Solitaire Necklace in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Made in the USA

$675

Our gemologist: A 1/2 carat lab-grown diamond in four prongs, fixed on an 18 inch gold chain. Prongs let in more light from the sides.

April Birthstone Necklace · Diamond in Solid 14K Gold

April Birthstone Necklace · Diamond in Solid 14K Gold

Made in the USA

From $1,100

Our gemologist: A 1/4 carat natural diamond, 4mm, in a four-prong solitaire. Our April birthstone necklace, in yellow, white or rose gold.

Natural diamond accents

Small natural diamonds add light to a design without making it formal.

Star Necklace with Natural Diamond in Solid 14K Gold

Star Necklace with Natural Diamond in Solid 14K Gold

Made in the USA

From $900

Our gemologist: A gold star with one natural diamond at its center. A quiet first diamond that works every day.

Diamond Crescent Moon Necklace in Solid 14K Gold

Diamond Crescent Moon Necklace in Solid 14K Gold

Made in the USA

From $710

Our gemologist: Small natural diamonds set along the inner curve of a gold crescent moon.

Diamond Bar Bracelet in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Diamond Bar Bracelet in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Made in the USA

$575

Our gemologist: Natural diamonds set in a slim gold bar that sits flat on the wrist and stacks with a watch.

A line of diamonds

1 Carat Lab-Grown Diamond Tennis Bracelet in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

1 Carat Lab-Grown Diamond Tennis Bracelet in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

$2,040

Our gemologist: A continuous line of lab-grown diamonds, 1 carat total, 7 1/4 inches. The tennis bracelet look at a lab-grown price.

The 4Cs, explained simply

Cut is how well a diamond is proportioned and polished to send light back to the eye. Color runs from D (colorless) toward Z (a warmer, yellowish tint). Clarity describes tiny internal features called inclusions; most are invisible without magnification. Carat is weight, not size, although heavier stones usually look larger. GIA, which created the grading system, notes that an expertly cut diamond can look brilliant even with lower color and clarity grades, which is why our gemologist puts cut first.

Lab-grown diamonds are diamond, not an imitation. GIA explains that they have essentially the same chemical composition, crystal structure and physical properties as natural diamonds, and that only a gemological laboratory or specialized instruments can reliably tell the two apart. A natural diamond formed deep in the Earth over a very long time; a lab-grown diamond is grown in weeks. Every lab-grown piece in our store says so in its title.

Lab-grown or natural?

Choose lab-grown when you want a larger, whiter diamond for the money: a pair of 1 carat studs or a 1/2 carat pendant becomes realistic. Choose natural when the stone's age and rarity matter to you, or for a small accent where the price difference is modest. Both are equally hard and equally bright when well cut, so the choice is about budget and what feels right to you.

Our gemologist's buying tips

  • Spend on cut first. A well-cut stone in a slightly lower color or clarity grade looks brighter than a poorly cut one with top grades.
  • Look for honest labels. Lab-grown should always be named as lab-grown. If a listing just says "diamond" with no origin, ask.
  • Match the setting to your day. A bezel guards the edge and suits active wear; prongs show more of the stone and let in more light.
  • Carat is weight, not quality. A smaller, well-cut stone often looks better than a bigger, dull one.
  • Clean it often. Lotion and skin oil cloud a diamond fast. A weekly soak in warm, soapy water keeps it bright.

Common questions

Are lab-grown diamonds fake?

No. A lab-grown diamond is diamond, with the same crystal structure and hardness as a natural one. Only its origin is different, and it must be labeled lab-grown.

Can you tell a lab-grown diamond from a natural one by looking?

No. Even a trained jeweler needs laboratory testing or specialized instruments to separate them.

What is the most important of the 4Cs?

Cut, because it decides how much light comes back to your eye. Color and clarity come next, and carat sets the size.

Do lab-grown diamonds get cloudy over time?

No. A diamond does not change, whether natural or lab-grown. A cloudy look is almost always oil or soap on the surface and washes off.

Is a diamond accent worth it?

Yes, if you want light without a big price. Small diamonds add brightness to a pendant or bracelet and are easy to wear every day.

All diamond jewelry →  ·  All earrings →  ·  How to buy jewelry that lasts →  ·  Holiday gift guide →

Back to blog