Collection of gold rings, bracelets, and chains with gemstones arranged on a textured surface

How to Buy Jewelry That Lasts: Metal, Settings, Clasps and Chains

Jewelry that lasts is made of karat gold or sterling silver all the way through, holds its stones in secure settings, and hangs on a well-made chain and clasp. Most jewelry fails at the plating, the prongs or the chain, not the stone. Here is what to check before you buy, with our gemologist's picks from $75.

Quick facts

Metal 14K gold or sterling silver, the same metal all the way through. Plated pieces wear through over time
The stamp 14K or 585 for gold, 925 for sterling, ideally beside a maker's mark
Settings A bezel (a metal rim around the stone) is the most secure. Prongs show more stone but need a yearly check
Chains Solid, evenly made links. Fine chains are lovely but snag more easily
Earrings Hinged hoops and snug friction backs stay put. Check that backs grip firmly
Upkeep A wash in warm, soapy water and a jeweler's check on stones and clasps once a year

Choose pieces built to last

Bezel settings: stones held all the way around

A smooth rim of gold around the stone guards its edge from knocks and keeps it from catching on clothes.

Lab-Grown Diamond Three-Stone Bracelet in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Lab-Grown Diamond Three-Stone Bracelet in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Made in the USA

$740

Our gemologist: Three lab-grown diamonds, each in a gold bezel, on a 7 inch 14K bracelet. Bezels are the right choice at the wrist, where knocks happen.

December Birthstone Bracelet · Blue Zircon in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

December Birthstone Bracelet · Blue Zircon in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Made in the USA

$395

Our gemologist: A 3mm natural blue zircon in a polished bezel, on an adjustable gold chain. Zircon can be brittle, so the bezel matters here.

January Birthstone Ring · Garnet in Solid 14K Gold

January Birthstone Ring · Garnet in Solid 14K Gold

Made in the USA

From $725

Our gemologist: A 3mm natural garnet bezel-set on a slim band. Low and smooth, so it does not snag. Available in size 7.

Earrings that stay put

Lost earrings are the most common jewelry loss. Choose closures you trust.

Hinged Hoop Earrings in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Hinged Hoop Earrings in Solid 14K Yellow Gold

Made in the USA

$495

Our gemologist: 10mm hinged hoops in 14K yellow gold. The hinge snaps closed, so there is no separate back to lose.

Star Stud Earrings in Solid 14K Gold

Star Stud Earrings in Solid 14K Gold

Made in the USA

From $280

Our gemologist: Petite polished gold stars with friction backs. All metal, no stones to loosen, so they are made for daily wear.

Chains: the part that wears first

A chain moves all day. Solid links and a good clasp are what keep a pendant on.

1.25mm Rope Chain in Solid 14K Gold

1.25mm Rope Chain in Solid 14K Gold

Made in the USA

From $530

Our gemologist: Twisted 14K links that are sturdier than their fine look suggests, with a lobster clasp. A strong base for a pendant.

1mm Cable Chain in Solid 14K Gold

1mm Cable Chain in Solid 14K Gold

Made in the USA

From $330

Our gemologist: A fine 1mm 14K cable chain in 16, 18 or 20 inches, with a spring ring clasp. Best for light pendants and charms.

1.3mm Cable Chain in Sterling Silver

1.3mm Cable Chain in Sterling Silver

Solid sterling silver · Made in the USA

From $75

Our gemologist: A 1.3mm sterling silver cable chain with a lobster clasp. Sterling all the way through, so it polishes back to bright.

Karat gold, plated and filled: what the labels mean

Start with the metal, because nothing else matters if it wears through. 14K gold and sterling silver are the same metal all the way through, so a scratch can be polished out and a piece can be repaired for decades. Plated jewelry is a thin layer of gold over another metal; it looks the same on day one but wears at the edges, clasps and anywhere it rubs. The FTC's jewelry buying guide explains that gold-filled, gold overlay and electroplated items must be marked as such, and advises looking for a maker's mark next to any karat stamp.

Stones need the same honesty. The FTC advises asking whether a gemstone has been treated and whether it needs special care, and says lab-created stones should be clearly labeled. Knowing a stone's treatment tells you how to look after it, which is half of making it last.

How to make it last

Put jewelry on last, after lotion and perfume, and take it off for swimming, the gym and housework. Store pieces apart so harder stones cannot scratch softer ones, and hang or lay chains flat so they do not knot. Once a year, have a jeweler check prongs and clasps; a loose prong caught early costs very little to fix.

Our gemologist's buying tips

  • Check the clasp first. A flimsy clasp or a thin jump ring is the first thing to fail. Open and close it before you buy.
  • Choose bezels for active wear. Rings and bracelets take the most knocks, and a bezel guards the stone best.
  • Match chain to pendant. A heavy pendant on a very fine chain wears both. Size the chain up for weight.
  • Pick hard stones for daily rings. Diamond, sapphire and ruby handle daily wear best; softer stones suit pendants.
  • Fewer, better pieces. One 14K pendant worn for twenty years costs less per wear than a drawer of plated pieces.

Common questions

What jewelry lasts the longest?

Pieces made of 14K gold, platinum or sterling silver all the way through, with stones in secure settings. They can be cleaned, polished and repaired for decades.

Is gold-plated jewelry worth buying?

For a trend piece, it can be. For something you will wear every day for years, choose karat gold, because plating wears through.

Does 14K gold last forever?

The metal does not tarnish or rust, and scratches can be polished out, so with basic care a 14K piece can last a lifetime.

What is the most secure setting for a stone?

A bezel, a smooth rim of metal around the whole stone. It guards the edge and does not catch on clothes.

How often should I have my jewelry checked?

Once a year for pieces with stones. A jeweler can tighten prongs and check clasps before anything is lost.

Gold and silver chains →  ·  Diamond jewelry →  ·  What is 14K gold? →  ·  Diamond buying guide →

Back to blog